Wednesday, November 1, 2017

Copied before 1700 after Raphael

Anonymous Italian artist
Standing nude men
(after a drawing by Raphael)
before 1520
drawing
British Museum

Anonymous Italian printmaker
St Michael the Archangel defeating the Devil
 (after a painting by Raphael, now in the Louvre)
ca. 1520-60
engraving
British Museum

Antoine Lafréry (publisher)
Psyche holding the flask of beauty, carried to Olympus by putti
(after a fresco by Raphael at the Farnesina in Rome)
ca. 1530-50
engraving
British Museum

"We are not aware of confronting a tour de force in composition; what we admire is an image of serene and relaxed simplicity.  I know no better description of this miraculous emergence of classic form than two stanzas from a poem by Friedrich Schiller, who, perhaps, gave more thought to these mysteries than any other creative artist.  They come in his philosophic poem on Ideal and Life, and though their beauty is naturally much tarnished in translation I should like to quote them for the thought they express:

                           When, to wake a soul in inert matter,
                           When, to be a living form's begetter
                           Genius burns, on glorious deeds intent,
                           Then with every nerve and muscle straining
                           Without respite and without complaing
                           Let his thought subdue the element.
                           Only zeal that shrinks from no endeavour
                           Finds the well of truth beneath the rock;
                           Only heavy hammerblows will ever 
                           Shape the hard and brittle marble block.

                           But as soon as Beauty's realm is gained
                           Heaviness which over matter reigned
                           Sinks to dust and disappears from sight.
                           Not the fruit of toiling and devising,
                           Light and lithe, as though from nothing rising
                           Stands the image to the eye's delight.
                           In triumphant victory have vanished
                           All the storms with which the work began.
                           The perfection of its form has banished
                           All the insufficiencies of man.

One almost envies Schiller the metaphysical religion of beauty on which he could build his description of the artistic process.  His poem is based on a Platonic scheme of things, with the realm of ideas or perfect forms in heaven and embodied in the work of art.  It is not always realized that nearly everything we say or try to say about these mysteries is couched in a vocabulary which stems from classical aesthetics and carries with it all the metaphysical implications of Greek thought.

For what can we say to describe this feeling of a perfect solution that we have in front of such a masterpiece?  I have called it self-sufficient, self-contained, classical, and if you read more about these things you will find books new and old ringing the changes on various synonyms of organic unity and integration.  I remember how, when I read the proofs of my Story of Art, I discovered to my mortification that I had said of nearly every work of art I particularly admired that it formed a 'harmonious whole'.  I tried to ration the phrase in my text, but it has never ceased to haunt me." 

 E.H. Gombrich, from Raphael's Madonna della Sedia, the Charlton Lecture delivered at King's College in the University of Durham in 1955, reprinted in the author's essay collection Norm and Form (London: Phaidon Press, 1966)

Anonymous Italian printmaker
Caryatid
(after a fresco by Raphael 
in the Stanza di Eliodoro at the Vatican)
ca. 1550-1650
engraving
British Museum

Anonymous Italian printmaker
Caryatid
(after a fresco by Raphael
in the Stanza di Eliodoro at the Vatican)
ca. 1550-1650
engraving
British Museum

Julius Goltzius
Sacrifice of Abraham
(after a ceiling-fresco by Raphael in the Stanza di Eliodoro at the Vatican)
before 1595
engraving
British Museum

Cherubino Alberti
Entombment
(after a drawing formerly in the Arundel collection, attributed to Raphael, now lost)
before 1615
drawing
British Museum

Lucas Vorsterman
Entombment
(after a drawing formerly in the Arundel collection, attributed to Raphael, now lost)
1628
engraving
British Museum

Anonymous Italian artist
Decorative panel with grotesques
(after a fresco by Raphael on a window-embrasure 
in the Stanza della Segnatura at the Vatican)
ca. 1600-1700
drawing
British Museum

Anonymous Italian printmaker
Two Figures from The Ecstasy of St Cecilia
 (after altarpiece by Raphael, now in the Pinacoteca Nazionale, Bologna)
ca. 1600-1700
engraving
British Museum

Anonymous Italian printmaker
Adam and Eve with Cain and Abel
(after a fresco-design by Raphael for the Vatican Loggia, executed by assistants)
ca. 1600-1700
engraving, etching
British Museum

Anonymous Italian printmaker
God creating the animals
(after a fresco-design by Raphael for the Vatican Loggia, executed by assistants)
ca. 1600-1700
engraving
British Museum

Anthony van Dyck
At top: copy of Raphael's portrait of Pope Leo X with Cardinals, now in Palazzo Pitti
At bottom: copy of Titian 's portrait of Capitano da Mar, now in a private collection
before 1641
drawing
British Museum

Luca Giordano
Jacob's Dream
(after a fresco by Raphael in the Stanza di Eliodoro at the Vatican)
ca. 1650-55
drawing
British Museum